Molly Dattilo’s Death: How Did She Die? Was She Killed?


Molly Dattilo appeared to have vanished with out a hint in July of 2004, as she was attending a celebration at her house advanced. Nonetheless, the investigation into what happened appeared to result in only a few clues and no explanations. Molly’s story is featured as one of many two instances highlighted on the present ‘Nonetheless a Thriller: Indiana Unsolved,’ which is broadcast on Investigation Discovery. Over the course of a few years, the household has struggled mightily to attain decision, since they’ve been prevented from acquiring satisfactory info. So, in case you had been interested by what grew to become of Molly, here’s what we all know to be the case.

Molly Dattilo

Molly Dattilo

How Did Molly Dattilo Die?

Molly was the ninth and closing little one born into the household, and she or he spent her childhood in Madison, Indiana. The younger girl possessed a wide range of constructive traits, together with expertise, ambition, sociability, and trustworthiness. Molly was not solely profitable within the classroom, but in addition a gifted athlete. Consequently, she obtained a working scholarship to attend Jap Kentucky College. Every thing gave the impression to be going splendidly properly for the 22-year-old man. She attended Indiana College-Purdue College’s summer time session in Indianapolis in 2004, with the intention of submitting an software for “American Idol” at a later time. Molly’s day on July 6, 2004, started with the identical routine as another day. She shared an house in Indianapolis along with her brother on the time, and so they each known as that metropolis dwelling.

After getting some necessities and going to her classes at roughly 7 o’clock within the night, Molly went to a close-by quick meals restaurant handy in her software for a place there. After that, Molly attended a celebration that was held at her house advanced. Molly known as her pal from a pay cellphone situated in a petroleum station three miles away from her house at roughly 11 o’clock at night time. Sadly, the decision was lower off earlier than the good friend might end their sentence. After that, nobody ever heard from or about her once more. After greater than a decade had handed, Molly’s household determined in 2017 to formally acknowledge that she had handed away. Nonetheless, the rationale for loss of life can’t be decided presently.

Molly Dattilo’s Death

Molly Dattilo’s Dying

Was Molly Dattilo Killed?

Molly got here into a well-known face as she was on her solution to the quick meals institution, and that particular person jogged their reminiscence about the truth that she was carrying her cellphone. After a while, the machine was situated within her flat. On the social gathering held at her constructing on the night of July 6, 2004, she grew to become acquainted with John Shelton. She was launched to him by certainly one of her different shut friends. Following their departure from the social gathering, the 2 went on a ship tour after which ate dinner at a Taco Bell, in line with the findings of the inquiry. The decision got here in at roughly 11 o’clock at night time and was comprised of a payphone, which was situated three miles away within the different path from the house.

When John was questioned later, he confessed that he was with Molly on the time that she made the decision, however he claimed that he had dropped her off at dwelling after the decision was completed. He was the final one who had seen her alive at any cut-off date. Nick, Molly’s brother, didn’t instantly report his sister lacking as a result of it was not out of the odd for Molly to embark on unplanned journeys. Nick believed that Molly had returned dwelling safely. However, Nick grew to become involved when Molly nonetheless hadn’t returned dwelling or been in contact with anybody by July 8, 2004. He contacted the authorities, however they didn’t take his report severely as a result of they thought she had left on her personal volition.

Nonetheless, all of Molly’s gadgets, together with her pockets, id, automobile, and cellphone, had been nonetheless contained in the flat when the police arrived, which led them to suspect that foul play had been dedicated. Nonetheless, the authorities lacked a major quantity of data to observe up on. The household continued to speak about Molly and her disappearance within the hopes that different leads would floor. In accordance with the episode, two years after John’s disappearance, they determined to make use of a personal investigator to be able to discover out extra details about him. He has been out and in of jail for a wide range of offenses all through his life.

When the household determined to go public with John’s identify, it was claimed on the present that his earlier girlfriends confided within the household about how John made them really feel uncomfortable and threatened. They claimed that John boasted about doing one thing to Molly after which threatened to do the identical factor to them in the event that they didn’t hold their distance. A few of the different women within the household described how, when he was drunk, he would choke them. The truth that there was neither a physique nor another proof made it unimaginable for the authorities to put John below arrest. In October of 2008, the police got further info.

In accordance with this system, the tipster asserted that John spoke to his father, Edward, on the night of Molly’s disappearance and instructed him that he had inadvertently killed another person. Allegedly in response, Edward requested him to discover a appropriate burial spot for the deceased. Not lengthy after that, the investigation into Molly’s disappearance was modified to a murder probe by the authorities. John has been the one particular person of curiosity within the investigation all through all of those years. In 2010, the household prevailed in a wrongful declare introduced towards John and Edward, which resulted in an award of $3.5 million to Molly’s family members. The Sheltons, then again, failed to seem in courtroom, main the household to imagine that they’d by no means see the cash once more.

On the present, it was revealed that John is presently serving time for drug trafficking and armed robbery-related crimes, and that he’ll grow to be eligible for parole within the 12 months 2038. Molly’s household determined to formally acknowledge her passing in September of 2017, assuming that she had handed away on July 6, 2004. Celestra Dewey, her sister, acknowledged that “at this second, we’re working below the belief that she has handed away.” In gentle of this, I don’t think about it to be a type of give up. Even when somebody has been declared legally lifeless, that doesn’t imply that you’ll quit on the lookout for them at any level.

The publish Molly Dattilo’s Dying: How Did She Die? Was She Killed? appeared first on